Providing Expert Solutions For Projects Worldwide

Providing Expert Solutions For Projects Worldwide

Phone: (610) 640-9600

Fax: (484) 301-0969

Beware of the Gray to be Green

Beware of the Gray to be Green

Donald R. Keer
MDCSystems®
Consulting Engineer

As companies strive to improve energy consumption, promote environmental responsibility and improve the use of sustainable fuel sources to either generate revenues or improve their bottom lines the risks are not always in the determination of capital budgets, project scheduling or execution but in the gaps between technology unit operations. Renewable energy facilities can have a dozen or more process unit operations, each with proven technologies yet at the unit interfaces the process can break down leading to reduced efficiencies, higher than expected start-up costs and lost profits.

Renewable energy comes in many forms. There are fuels such as ethanol and biodiesel which support existing engine and transportation technologies. There are also electrical generation operations such as biomass, animal waste and municipal solid waste which recycle waste streams into a cleaner form of energy. In both of these areas the objective is to reduce the amount of “new” carbon released into the atmosphere and reduce greenhouse gases. While most of the technologies employed today are well established it is at the interface between technologies a project can fail.

A recent example is an electrical generation system which used gasification of biomass pellets formed from animal waste. The initial drying process supplied as a turnkey unit exceeded expectations during start-up. The dryers efficiently removed moisture down to less than 10% by mass. Once the material reached the pelletizing process it was found to be too dry to form pellets. This issue required process re-design in the middle of the commissioning process delaying start-up and resulting in substantial revenue losses.

Another example occurred quite frequently in the biodiesel boom during the past few years. Claims by reactor designers focused on transit time within the reactor unit operation. While these reactors did improve mixing they did not catalyze the reaction to force it to completion any faster. The chemical reaction constants are independent of the mechanical mixing. Completion of the reaction still takes 0:30 minutes to 1 hour depending on the conditions. The low transit time within the reactor itself just transferred to completion of the reaction downstream to the separation processes. Separation of product and glycerin took longer and required more storage volume. The largest issue created by the low transit time reactors was that they were sold at a significant premium over a traditional constant stir tank reactor traditionally used.

As projects move forward it is wise to review the unit operations interface. A proven technology base makes the planning, budgeting and construction easier. The issues arise because the material being handled can change day to day and the operations are being placed in new configurations. A well planned and executed project can experience significant cost over runs and delays at the very end of construction, start-up and commissioning because of required process modification discovered during the end of the project.

Related Posts

Once Upon a Time in Construction: When Promises Fall Apart

Once Upon a Time in Construction: When Promises Fall Apart

Our client was distraught and blurted out “ they said it would work” and now we have to demolish it. How did this happen? During the mid-90’s it was feared by the EPA that landfills would soon be at capacity to accept sewage sluge and the EPA had recently banned ocean...

read more
MDCSystems® Taking Off with Commercial Drones

MDCSystems® Taking Off with Commercial Drones

MDCSystems® has recently entered the commercial drone industry with its drone for various inspection and engineering evaluation services. The future for the commercial drone industry looks very bright. In 2015 the U.S. commercial drone market size was an estimated...

read more
Change Orders: Maximizing Benefits for Owners

Change Orders: Maximizing Benefits for Owners

Ronald F. Parisi, P.E.
Former MDC Systems® Project Director

Owners involved in ongoing construction projects are virtually unanimous in recognizing the need to minimize the number and amount of change orders as a way to keep the project costs within budget. In viewing change orders with only this in mind, however, owners may tend to overlook the benefits that the change order process offers to owners. The primary benefits afforded by the change order process are that it allows owners the flexibility to respond quickly, to capitalize upon opportunities and to mitigate problems — both of which frequently arise during the course of construction.

Continue Reading

read more

0 Comments