|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Fukushima Dai-Ichi:
When Culture Trumps Engineering Judgment and the Scientific Method By Robert C. McCue, PE MDCSystems® Consulting Engineer In two recent articles1, MDCSystems® has examined the Fukushima Dai-Ichi nuclear plant explosion and meltdown disaster. Recently a Japanese investigative report2 has provided new insight into the cultural conditions which precipitated the disaster and contributed to the expanse and breadth of the effects of the continuing radiation contamination. While it is well-known that a tsunami generated from a powerful undersea earthquake initiated the incident, what has been difficult to understand is how a modern society with very sophisticated engineering and management skills ignored established nuclear industry standards and practices (Design Basis Events) and safety guidance (Station Blackout) norms and failed to anticipate the events that occurred leading to the nuclear plant meltdown conditions.
As discussed in MDC's previous articles1 on the Fukishma disaster, the most obvious site engineering failure was the design elevation specified for units one through four. In addition, well-established accident scenarios such as station blackout conditions and nuclear safety related emergency power system design criteria were apparently ignored and directly contributed to immediate and long-term effects of the nuclear incident. The delayed and ineffective Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO) response to the initial event exacerbated the already serious and deteriorating plant conditions and likely contributed to the ongoing deadly effects of the radiation releases. The report3 to the Japanese parliament stated that "The Fukushima nuclear plant accident was the result of collusion between the government, the regulators and TEPCO and the lack of governance by said parties." The report goes on to state, "We believe that the root causes were the organizational and regulatory systems that supported faulty rationales for decisions and actions." In his introduction Chairman Kurokawa said that "cultural traits had caused the disaster." The Chairman continued his criticism by saying that "What must be admitted - very painfully - is that this was a disaster 'Made in Japan.' Its fundamental causes are to be found in the ingrained conventions of Japanese culture: our reflective obedience; our reluctance to question authority; our devotion to 'sticking with the program; our groupism and our insularity."
-------------------------------------------------------------
1 MDC Advisor, April 2012 and MDCAdvisor, July 2012 2 Fukushima reactor meltdown was a man-made disaster, says official report; Guardian, Fukishma Meldown, July 2012 3 Head Investigator Kiyoshi Kurokawa, Japanese Parliamentary Panel MDCSystems® Joins ABA in Paradise; January 30-31, 2014 MDCSystems® will join distinguished colleagues at the pristine and calm aquamarine waters of Atlantis Paradise Island, Bahamas, for the 2014 Mid-Winter American Bar Association Forum on the Construction Industry. The program includes sessions on best practices in both construction risk management and arbitration, as well as recovery schedules, litigation holds and budgets, and ethical issues arising as a result of data stored in today's smartphones, tablets and The Cloud.
The MDC Exhibit
As a long-time sponsor of the ABA, MDC® is also pleased to exhibit at this event. Please be sure to visit MDC's booth to collect company information, chat with our professionals or just to put your name into the drawing for a chance to WIN a Kindle Fire 7", 16GB Table with Wifi. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||
We do not sell, share or distribute email addresses to or with any party outside of our office. Copyright © 2010 MDCSystems®. All rights reserved. The newsletter is protected by U.S. and international copyright and intellectual property laws. The commercial use of MDCSystems® materials without the express written consent of MDCSystems® is prohibited by law. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||